Unethical cruises by Abdulaziz Mohammed
Research paper
Abstract
Cruise ships in the Caribbean Sea are so big, that they are seriously causing some problems affecting everything in that area. By comparison, pollution is the worst problem. Cruises are dumping many substances such as sewage, oil, noxious chemical etc. Furthermore, it’s difficult to deal with them. There are three solutions to solve this problem. First, we should enforce the law more strictly. Second, we should support the Coast Guard to keep an eye on them. Last, we should use radar technology to catch these cruises more easily at their crime scenes.
Cruise companies are companies that have huge boats that take people from country to country in the Caribbean Sea. They have been getting bigger and bigger over time; according to “Groups seek tougher cruises ship waste laws” by John Pain (2005, par. 4), “the cruise industry has gotten so big that all its ships together could hold each of Miami’s 360,000 residents with room to spare”. However, the bigger it becomes, the more troubles it makes. There are three major problems that the cruise companies cause. At first, these cruises are American companies that pretend to be from other countries by changing their own flag; obviously, they do this to escape paying taxes and escape application of the US rules. Subsequently, they make their crew work long hours with an unfair paycheck; “These employees log 10, 12, or even 14-hour days, washing laundry or peeling potatoes for as little as $550 a month” (Foust, 2005, par. 5). The last and the most important problem is that they are polluting the Caribbean Sea without any responsibility, by dumping a huge amount of sewage and waste in the water. According to Mohammed, Torres & Obenshain (1998, par. 3), "A 1990 study determined that each passenger on board a cruise vessel generates an average of 0.32-3.5 Kilograms of waste per day". This problem impacts not only the environment, but also the people; many people die because of water pollution every year, and this problem will increase and get bigger, unless we act immediately. This problem is seriously dangerous; and it is interrupting people’s lives and the environment at the same time.
We shouldn’t stand and watch these criminals destroying such a beautiful place as the Caribbean Sea. So, I have three strong solutions that will solve this problem.
First, we should enforce the law of cleaning wastes before dumping them in the water; “Each ship generates up to 1 million gallons of waste per week” (Pain, 2005, par. 7). This is a huge amount of waste. In addition, it is not only liquid waste, but also solid waste, such as domestic garbage, packing materials, plastics, etc. (Mohammed, Torres & Obenshain, 1998). So the law applies to both liquid and solid waste, which makes it more complex to deal with.
According to Pain (2005), there is a law; it is aimed at huge boats; and they should clean their sewage before throwing it into the sea, but no one applies this law. This is an appropriate law; therefore, the government can make it effective if they enforce it. However, the US government must enforce this law.
Some people might say that this law doesn't affect or do anything, but this law will make a big decrease in the pollution of the Caribbean Sea; and will make the cruises follow the pollution standards; the reason is that it will be a big threat to the cruise companies. According to Mohammed, Torres & Obenshain (1998, par. 2), "because of stricter legislation, greater public scrutiny, and an increase industry awareness, the Miami-based cruise industry is adopting pollution prevention techniques that reduce or eliminate disposal at sea".
Indeed, using these filters on these ships is very reliable and would save a lot of money. Pain (2005, par. 18) says that, "Teri Shore of the Bluewater Network acknowledges that the advanced treatment system on many cruise ships are a huge improvement over the conventional once."
Second, we should give the Coast Guard the resources it needs to patrol the sea and deal with lawbreaking polluters. In one way or another, the Coast Guards are the police of the sea; they do what the government regulates, and have the authority to do it. The Coast Guard has a lot of jobs to do; for example, they are responsible for security, criminal activity on the water, departure, environment, illegal immigrants and much more. Altschul (2005, par. 20) quotes Admiral Loy as saying, “The rule of Coast Guard is to size up each case, Coordinate actions with other agencies, exercise legal authority, and utilize coastal assets, command structure, and provide command and control.” So it has a lot of essential jobs to do.
Since, there are some things the government considers important, and others it considers more important, the government cares less about the environment and pollution, and they don’t give enough money to support the Coast Guard for this purpose. The Coast Guard takes just 11.07 percent from its budget for environmental protection (Altschul, 2005). In fact, the Coast Guard can solve this problem easily and reliably,
Unquestionably, the Coast Guard can keep an eye on the cruises; for instance, check where they dump their sewage, and check if it’s clean or not. According to Mohammed, Torres & Obenshain (1998, par. 14), "The Coast Guard effectively examines a vessel’s waste management and containment systems during each inspection”. If the cruises are polluting the Sea they will have evidence and proof of them doing it, so the Coast Guards will apply the first solution, which is enforcing the law. As has been noted, supporting the Coast Guard with budget and supplies can be a great to help to reduce this incident.
Last, we should use radar technology. Using technology is very important for the Coast Guards in their work. “Better technology is also assisting the process” Mohammed, Torres & Obenshain (1998, par. 41). The radar technology will save the government a lot of money and time, because these radars catch the pollution in the sea water, find what kind of waste or toxic element it’s, and at what time they was dumped in the water. Moreover, the radar will work twenty-four hours a day, so it will help the Coast Guard and other environmental groups to deal with this problem more securely and easily. NASA (2005, par. 3) quotes DiGiacomo as saying, "The key to evaluating and managing pollution hazards in urban coastal regions is accurate, timely data. Since such hazards are usually localized, dynamic and episodic, they're hard to asses using oceanographic field sampling. Space-based imaging radar works day and night, regardless of clouds, detecting pollution deposits on the sea surface. Combined with field surveys and other observations including shore-based radar data, it greatly improves our ability to detect and monitor such hazards".
Equally important, this radar technology can find the cause of the pollution, since it has been examined by many scientists and people. To illustrate, NASA (2005, par. 3), about pollution in Southern California, says that, "The study described three major pollutant sources for Southern California: storm water runoff, wastewater discharge and natural hydrocarbon seepage". As I have shown, this technology can be so specific that it can give a list of the sources. Therefore, there will be scientific evidence of these cruises polluting the sea.
In conclusion, polluting such a nice place as the Caribbean Sea is not a decision to make, especially if it's from these irresponsible cruise companies. As I have noted, we should do something before it's destroyed; and with these solutions we could definitely solve this problem. Enforce the law that can be a threat to these cruise companies. Then, support the Coast Guard, which will make the cruise companies aware of them. Finally, get radar technology; thereby, to catch these cruises more easily. I wish that people will take this problem more seriously, and think about fairness in this world, hopefully, this problem will be just written in a paper of a book, not in reality.
Bibliography:
Altschul, J. (2005, Dec 11). Coast Guard faces homeland security challenges. JINSA, Retrieved on Oct. 3, 2005 from http://www.jinsa.org/articles/articles.html/function/view/categoryid/1333/documentid/1328/history/3,2360,656,1333,1328
Foust, D. (2005, July 18). Not exactly the love boat. Business Week. Retrieved from Lexis-Nexis database, Aug. 25, 2005.
Markowitz, J. (2005, March 10). No smooth waters for cruise industry. Pittsburgh Tribune Review. Retrieved from Lexis-Nexis database, Aug. 25, 2005.
Mohammed., J, Torres, R., & Obenshain, E. (1998, Oct.). Waste reduction at sea: pollution prevention Strategies on Miami-Based cruise lines. Retrieved on Sep. 27, 2005 from http://www.umich.edu/~nppcpub/.
NASA. (2005, March 18). NASA researchers use imaging radar to detect coastal pollution. Retrieved on Sept. 27, 2005 from http://www.nasa.gov/centers/jpl/news/sar-031705.html.
Oleck, J. (2005, July 4). The seamy underside of cruise-line profits: huge returns derived from third wages. The Calgary Herald. Retrieved from Lexis-Nexis database, Aug. 25, 2005.
Pain, J. (2005, April 14). Groups seek tougher cruise ship waste laws. Associated Press Online. Retrieved from Lexis-Nexis database, Sept. 6, 2005.
Surfrider foundation. (2005). Cruise ship pollution. Retrieved on Sept. 28, 2005 from http://www.surfrider.org/a-z/cruise.htm.
Uebersax, M. (1996, Aug.). Indecent proposal: cruise ship pollution in the Caribbean. Retrieved on Sep. 28, 2005 from http://www.planeta.com/planeta/96/0896cruise.html.
.
